WEEKLY NEWSLETTER

How to Use AI to Make Better, Faster Hiring Decisions

© CURRENT YEAR, AI Business Lab. All rights reserved.

Six months in, we’d paid more than $120,000 to a salesperson who hadn’t closed a single sale.

You’ve probably made a bad hire or two. I know I have.

Six months after we hired her, she still hadn’t closed a single sale. That was our fault as much as hers, because we let it run that long.

Back in 2018, a recruiting agency brought us an enterprise salesperson to sell consulting built on the Full Focus System. She was an Ivy League graduate, top of her class, and came from a Fortune 500 company. She looked great on paper and even better in the interviews. We were thrilled.

We paid her just north of $200,000 a year, and the agency took about 30% on top of that. We were sure she would kill it.

Unfortunately, she didn’t have a clue what she was doing, but she always told us just enough to buy another week. So it dragged on, and on, and on.

Finally, in a meeting with Megan, our CEO (and my eldest daughter), we decided to face reality. “Dad, this isn’t working, and it’s never going to work with this person. We need to cut our losses.”

So, we let her go and gave up on the opportunity. We’d had enough.

By that time we’d paid more than $120,000, counting benefits and the recruiting agency’s fee. Worse, the lost opportunity ran to hundreds of thousands of dollars. It was an expensive lesson.

A bad hire is usually a skipped step, not bad luck. You can let AI run your hiring process, and still make every decision about a real person, by following five steps.

We believed what we saw on paper and in the interviews. We didn’t have a process that would have caught the gap sooner.

You don’t have to hire on gut feel. That’s what AI hiring should mean: AI runs the process, and you make the call.

People often call it AI recruiting. I mean using AI to run your process, not buying another recruiting tool.

Step #1: Do the Pre-Work

Start with one role and one hiring project. I set that up in Grok Bot first, and the same approach works in Claude or ChatGPT. Save every later draft in that project so the next step can use it.

Here’s how to write a job description that helps you hire: don’t start with a task list. Picture the person who succeeds in this role a year from now, then let AI draft a vision script with the mission, the outcomes, and the competencies.

The scorecard method in the book Who by Geoff Smart and Randy Street starts with the outcomes you want from the role. 1 Add a short profile of who succeeds, a salary band, and a timeline, then let AI draft those artifacts while you decide. Aim for a complement to the manager, because a vague profile is worse than none.

Step #2: Sell the Role

About eight years ago, Megan and I decided to redesign our careers page. I said, “Let’s treat job candidates the same way we would treat a prospective customer.”

In other words, if we’re trying to attract world-class talent, we’re the seller; they’re the buyer. So what would make our offer super attractive? What would get them to click on the Apply button and say to themselves, “Wow, this is a company I want to work for”?

You can use AI to draft the posting and the careers page as sales copy, from the candidate’s point of view: what’s in it for them, with the pay range in plain words. 2 A job description tells people what the job is. A job ad makes the right person want it.

Also, plan your applicant emails before you post. When someone applies, instantly acknowledge receipt of their application. Then, email people you cut within forty-eight hours, so they’re not left wondering where they stand.

Step #3: Screen for Fit Before Charisma

Score every applicant against the job description before anyone gets charming in a room. Set the cutoff before you see the numbers. A person should review every score before anyone gets a yes or a no.

Left to myself, I tend to be pretty impulsive, and I trust my gut more than I should. I will spend the entire interview selling my company instead of evaluating the person.

A 2022 review of hiring research found that structured interviews were the top-ranked way to predict job performance. 3 The same questions, in the same order, beat a conversation that follows the charm.

Step #4: Test the Work, Then Interview

A one-way video interview through a tool like Spark Hire lets you hear from every remaining candidate without scheduling a single call. We’ve used it for about five years. The AI can draft six or seven questions from the job description, and every candidate gets the same questions in the same order.

Have a person watch the videos. Don’t hand that judgment to a tool.

Résumés and interviews tell you what someone says they can do. Homework shows you.

Assign paid work that looks like the real job. Pay $25 to $50 an hour, typically for eight to twenty hours, and set the rubric in advance.

We offer to pay for it, because we don’t want people to think we’re taking advantage of them. If they decline the fee and want to do it free, that’s fine.

Honesty about AI use on the assignment is required. Hiding it is disqualifying.

In a classic review of eighty-five years of hiring research, work-sample tests were among the strongest predictors of job performance. 4 That’s why the homework comes before the long interviews, not after.

About eighteen months ago, we hired an executive who didn’t have the best video interview or the strongest résumé. Another candidate outscored him on both. Then the two of them did the homework, and the difference was night and day.

The stronger résumé was only okay, but his homework was fabulous. He’s been one of the best hires we’ve probably made in the last five years, because we could see the real work he would be expected to produce.

Interview the people who proved they can do the work. If you’re in the debrief, go last so you don’t tip the scale.

A final dinner can tell you things a conference room won’t, including how the candidate treats the waitstaff. Spouses can join, and it’s a natural time to ask how the family feels about the move or the role.

Step #5: Close

Call with a verbal offer first. Then send the letter within fifteen minutes, and make it contingent on references and a background check.

Reference checks are the step most small business owners skip. Of all the reference check questions you can ask, the best is, “Would you hire [name] again, given the chance?”

The best people, especially if they’re still employed, often won’t let you call their supervisor until they have an offer in hand. That’s a common request, and one option is to make the offer tentative until that call happens. 5

Hold the other finalists until the offer is signed. Once it is, send them a clean pass note, because a respectful no is a referral opportunity.

Have an attorney review the employment agreement once. Go back only if the terms change in a substantive way.

Weeks, Not Six Months

Think back to that 2018 hire. With these steps, the homework or the references would have shown the gap in weeks, not six months, and more than $120,000 later.

You don’t have to repeat that bill. Start with the next seat you need to fill, let AI run the process, and keep every people decision in your own hands.

What’s the one hiring step you’re most tempted to skip, and what would it cost you to skip it again?

Comments

If you have a question about using AI in your hiring process, click here to send me an email. I read every one. Seriously. Your experiences help me write better content, and sometimes the best insights come from readers like you.

Transforming AI from noise to know-how,

Michael’s Signature

P.S. Consider the AI Business Lab Mastermind: Running a $1M+ business? You’re past the startup chaos but not quite at autopilot. That’s exactly where AI changes everything. The AI Business Lab Mastermind isn’t another networking group—it’s a brain trust of leaders who are already implementing, not just ideating. We’re talking real numbers, real strategies, real results. If you’re tired of being the smartest person in the room, this is your new room. 👉🏼Learn more and apply here.


REFERENCE

  1. Geoff Smart and Randy Street, Who: The A Method for Hiring (New York: Ballantine Books, 2008). ↩︎
  2. Smart and Street, Who. ↩︎
  3. Paul R. Sackett, Charlene Zhang, Christopher M. Berry, and Filip Lievens, “Revisiting Meta-Analytic Estimates of Validity in Personnel Selection: Addressing Systematic Overcorrection for Restriction of Range”, Journal of Applied Psychology 107, no. 11 (2022): 2040–2068. ↩︎
  4. Frank L. Schmidt and John E. Hunter, “The Validity and Utility of Selection Methods in Personnel Psychology: Practical and Theoretical Implications of 85 Years of Research Findings”, Psychological Bulletin 124, no. 2 (1998): 262–274. ↩︎
  5. “Reference Checking”, U.S. Office of Personnel Management. ↩︎

How I use AI in my writing process →